Earn more from your vacation rental

  • Unlock higher earnings
  • Leverage cutting-edge technology for enhanced performance
  • Receive 24/7 local care and support

Best Airbnb Management Companies in Key West

Key West, the southernmost point in the United States, is a tropical paradise known for its stunning sunsets, vibrant nightlife, and rich history. This island city in Florida is a popular vacation destination, making it an ideal location for owning a vacation rental. With its year-round warm weather, beautiful beaches, and a plethora of activities, Key West attracts tourists from all over the world. To make the most of this lucrative market, it's crucial to have a reliable Airbnb management company.

Our Methodology When Choosing the Best Airbnb Management Company

Our selection of the best Airbnb management companies in Key West is based on a comprehensive and meticulous process. We conducted extensive research, analyzing various factors such as the company's reputation, services offered, and years of experience in the industry. We also took into account guest reviews, focusing on their overall satisfaction, the cleanliness of the property, and the responsiveness of the host. Owner reviews were equally important, with emphasis on the company's ability to optimize rental income, maintain the property, and handle guest relations effectively.

Top 6 Airbnb Management Companies in Key West

  1. AvantStay: AvantStay tops our list due to its exceptional performance in both guest satisfaction and optimized rental income. They offer a tech-driven approach to vacation rental management, ensuring a seamless and luxurious experience for guests.

  2. TurnKey Vacation Rentals: Known for their full-service property management, TurnKey Vacation Rentals provides owners with peace of mind knowing their property is in good hands.

  3. Vacasa: Vacasa stands out for its comprehensive management services, including marketing, maintenance, and guest communication.

  4. Key West Vacation Property Managers: This local company is praised for its personalized service and deep knowledge of the Key West market.

  5. At Home in Key West: With over 20 years of experience, At Home in Key West offers reliable property management and a wide selection of vacation rentals.

  6. Last Key Realty: Last Key Realty is known for its luxury vacation rentals and exceptional guest services, ensuring a memorable stay for visitors.

What Airbnb management includes

  • Guest Management: Our Airbnb property management services prioritize exceptional guest management. We understand that the guest experience is paramount to the success of your Airbnb listing.

    • Communication: We ensure prompt and professional communication with guests from the moment they inquire about your listing until they check out. We handle all inquiries, bookings, and any issues that may arise during their stay.
    • Check-in/Check-out: We manage the check-in and check-out process, providing clear instructions and ensuring a smooth transition for guests.
    • Guest Reviews: We encourage guests to leave reviews and respond to them promptly, as this helps to improve your listing's visibility and attractiveness to potential guests.
  • Property Maintenance: We believe that a well-maintained property is key to attracting and retaining guests.

    • Cleaning Services: We arrange professional cleaning services after each guest's stay to ensure your property is always at its best.
    • Repairs and Maintenance: We coordinate any necessary repairs or routine maintenance, minimizing any inconvenience to guests and ensuring your property remains in top condition.
    • Inventory Management: We keep track of all property inventory, from linens to kitchen appliances, and replenish as needed.
  • Listing Optimization: We use proven strategies to optimize your Airbnb listing and increase its visibility.

    • Photography: We arrange professional photography to showcase your property in the best light.
    • Listing Description: We craft compelling, keyword-rich descriptions that highlight your property's unique features and amenities.
    • Pricing Strategy: We use dynamic pricing strategies that consider factors like demand, seasonality, and local events to maximize your revenue.
  • Revenue Maximization: Our goal is to help you maximize your Airbnb revenue.

    • Occupancy Rate Optimization: We use data-driven strategies to optimize your occupancy rates, balancing the need for high occupancy with the desire for high nightly rates.
    • Seasonal Adjustments: We adjust pricing and marketing strategies based on seasonality and local events to attract more bookings.
    • Performance Tracking: We regularly track and analyze your listing's performance to identify opportunities for improvement and revenue growth.

What to look for when choosing an Airbnb management company

  • Pricing and Revenue Model: When choosing an Airbnb management company, it's crucial to understand their pricing and revenue model. Some companies charge a flat fee, while others take a percentage of the rental income. It's important to find a company that offers transparent pricing with no hidden fees. The revenue model should also align with your financial goals. Some companies may offer a guaranteed income model, while others operate on a commission-based model where they earn more when you earn more.

  • Number of Listings: The number of listings a management company handles can give you an idea of their capacity and expertise. A company managing a large number of listings likely has a system in place to efficiently handle the demands of multiple properties. However, if a company has too many listings, they may not be able to provide personalized attention to each property.

  • Value and Services: Look for a company that provides a comprehensive range of services that add value to your property and enhance your guests' experience. These services may include professional photography, listing optimization, price management, 24/7 guest communication, cleaning and maintenance services, and more. The company should also provide regular performance reports and have a proactive approach to managing your property.

  • Guest Experience: The guest experience is paramount in the short-term rental industry. A good Airbnb management company will prioritize this and have strategies in place to ensure guests have a seamless and enjoyable stay. This could include a fast and efficient check-in process, availability of amenities, quick response to queries or issues, and a clean and well-maintained property.

  • Great Vendors: A great Airbnb management company will have strong relationships with reliable vendors. This includes professional cleaning services, maintenance and repair companies, and others who can ensure your property is always in top condition. They should also be able to negotiate good rates with these vendors, helping you save on operational costs.

  • Booking Channels: The company should be adept at managing multiple booking channels. This includes not only Airbnb, but also other platforms like Booking.com, VRBO, and more. They should have a strategy for optimizing your listing across these channels to maximize visibility and bookings.

  • Brand Reputation: The reputation of the management company is a key factor to consider. Look for a company with positive reviews and a strong track record in the industry. They should be known for their professionalism, reliability, and excellent service.

  • Owner Reviews and Reputation: Finally, consider the reviews and feedback from other property owners who have used the company's services. This can provide valuable insights into the company's strengths and weaknesses, and help you make an informed decision. Look for a company that is highly rated by owners and has a reputation for delivering on their promises.

What to ask your potential property manager

  1. Pricing and Revenue Model

    • What is your pricing model for property management services?
    • How do you calculate the revenue for each property?
    • Are there any additional costs or hidden fees?
    • How often will I receive payments and reports about my property's performance?
  2. Number of Listings

    • How many properties do you currently manage?
    • What types of properties do you specialize in?
    • How many of these properties are similar to mine in terms of size, location, and amenities?
  3. Value and Services

    • What services are included in your management fee?
    • How do you ensure the property is well-maintained and cared for?
    • What is your approach to property repairs and maintenance?
    • How do you handle emergencies or unexpected issues at the property?
  4. Guest Experience

    • How do you ensure a positive guest experience?
    • What is your process for handling guest complaints or issues?
    • How do you handle guest check-in and check-out?
    • What measures do you take to ensure guest safety and satisfaction?
  5. Great Vendors

    • Do you have a network of reliable vendors for maintenance and repairs?
    • How do you select and vet your vendors?
    • Do you have any partnerships or discounts with local businesses that could enhance the guest experience?
  6. Booking Channels and Brand Reputation

    • Which booking channels do you use to advertise the property?
    • How do you optimize the property listing for SEO?
    • How do you manage the property's online reputation?
    • What strategies do you use to increase the property's visibility and bookings?
  7. Owner Reviews and Reputation

    • Can you provide references or reviews from other property owners?

    • How do you handle negative reviews or feedback from owners?

    • What is your company's reputation in the short-term rental industry?

    • How do you maintain a positive relationship with property owners?


Looking to maximize your vacation rental income?

Contact AvantStay today

A step-by-step guide to starting an Airbnb in Key West

  • Find an Agent: Start your Airbnb journey by finding a reliable real estate agent who is familiar with Key West. They can guide you through the process of finding a suitable property, understanding local regulations, and negotiating a fair price.

  • Select and Purchase a Property: Once you have an agent, the next step is to select and purchase a property. Consider factors such as location, size, and potential for rental income. Your agent can help you find properties that meet your criteria and budget.

  • Update and Furnish the Property: After purchasing the property, you'll need to update and furnish it to make it appealing to potential guests. This could include painting, installing new appliances, and buying furniture and decor. Remember to create a comfortable and inviting space that reflects the charm of Key West.

  • Obtain Licenses and Permits: Before you can start renting out your property, you'll need to obtain the necessary licenses and permits. This may include a business license, a vacation rental permit, and a tax registration certificate. Check with local authorities or your real estate agent to understand what's required in Key West.

  • List Your Property: Once your property is ready and you have all the necessary paperwork, you can list it on Airbnb. Take high-quality photos, write a detailed description, and set a competitive price. Make sure to highlight any unique features of your property and the local area.

  • Host Your First Guest: After listing your property, it's time to host your first guest. Prepare the property by cleaning thoroughly, stocking up on essentials like toiletries and kitchen supplies, and leaving a welcome note or gift. Be available to answer any questions your guest may have and strive to provide a great experience to earn positive reviews.


To find the best investment for your next vacation rental property, work with AvantStay today.

Overall Takeaway

In conclusion, the role of a good management company cannot be overstated in the realm of short-term rental properties. They ensure smooth operations, provide excellent customer service, and optimize the property's visibility online. While there are several commendable Airbnb management companies in Key West, each with their unique strengths, AvantStay stands out as the best option. Their commitment to providing a seamless, high-quality experience for both property owners and guests sets them apart in the industry.

AvantStay's innovative approach to property management, coupled with their expertise in SEO performance, makes them a game-changer in the short-term rental market. They not only manage properties efficiently but also ensure they rank high in search results, thereby increasing visibility and bookings. Their dedication to excellence and consistent delivery of top-notch services makes them the best choice for Airbnb management in Key West. So, if you're looking for a management company that will take your property to the next level, AvantStay is the clear choice.

AvantStay’s property management and other real estate services are offered through its licensed legal entities. AvantStay, Inc. is a licensed real estate broker in the following states: California: License No. 02148122, Hawaii: License No. RB-23504, New York: License No. 10991236222, South Carolina: License No. 25532, Tennessee: License No. 265446. AvantStay Southwest, LLC is a licensed real estate broker in the following states: Arizona: License No. LC708660000, Texas: License No. 9012724. AvantStay CA, Inc. is licensed in California: License No. 2203672. AvantStay Southeast, LLC is a licensed real estate broker in the following states: Florida: License No. CQ1065931, Georgia: License No. 80864, North Carolina: License No. C36659, South Carolina: License No. 26123, Tennessee: License No. 265906, Virginia: License No: 0226035354. AvantStay Northeast, LLC is licensed in the following states: Massachusetts: License No: 424081, New York: License No. 10991237352. AvantStay Rocky Mountain is a licensed real estate broker in the following states: Colorado: License No. EC. 100098590, Nevada, Utah: License No. 13133696-CN00. AvantStay Pacific West, LLC is a licensed real estate broker in the following states: Oregon: License No. 201251747, Washington: License No. 23008676.

about AvantStay’s real estate brokerage.

AvantStay offers property management and other real estate services directly through AvantStay and through AvantStay Real Estate Inc. licensed subsidiaries. Click here for more information about AvantStay’s licensed real estate brokerage/property manager in your state.

Inspiration for your next trip
AshevilleCabin RentalsAustinVacation RentalsBerkshiresVacation RentalsBig BearCabin RentalsBlack MountainCabin RentalsBreckenridgeVacation RentalsCentral OregonVacation RentalsCharlestonVacation RentalsCoachella ValleyVacation RentalsCorpus ChristiVacation RentalsDestinVacation RentalsEmerald Coast - 30AVacation RentalsFort LauderdaleVacation RentalsHilton HeadVacation RentalsHudson ValleyVacation RentalsIsle of PalmsVacation RentalsJoshua TreeVacation RentalsLake ArrowheadCabin RentalsLake NormanRentalsLake TahoeCabin RentalsLos AngelesVacation RentalsMalibuVacation RentalsMarco IslandVacation RentalsMauiVacation RentalsNashvilleVacation RentalsNewport BeachVacation RentalsOahuVacation RentalsOregon CoastVacation RentalsOrlandoVacation RentalsPalm SpringsVacation RentalsPalm Springs HotelsPark CityVacation RentalsPaso RoblesVacation RentalsPoconosCabin RentalsPort AransasRentalsSan DiegoVacation RentalsScottsdaleVacation RentalsSedonaVacation RentalsSmoky MountainsCabin RentalsSonomaVacation RentalsSullivan's IslandVacation RentalsTellurideVacation RentalsTemeculaVacation RentalsVailVacation Rentals

This site uses cookies to provide you with a personalized experience

Learn more about AvantStay’s Privacy Policy.